Tuesday, April 5, 2016

Mostly what I expected...

There were not many things that surprised me while reading Julius Caesar.  We already had previous experience with the stories from Plutarch and HBO’s Rome, but I was a little surprised that the play wasn’t really about Caesar at all.  I did not expect him to be killed in the third act while there was still two more left in the play.  What would the rest of the book be about?

While I was reading the last two acts, it made sense to me why they were important (even though they were not very exciting or interesting.)  Brutus and Antony constructed their own armies and went to battle against each other.  Antony was fighting to avenge Caesar’s death and Brutus was just trying to put an end to the tyranny and power struggle once and for all.  But this war just seemed completely childish to me.  It didn’t seem like there was real reason to have a war. 

 
 Cassius even commanded someone to kill him for no real reason.  He was mistaken that his friend was captured by the enemy and couldn’t bear to live anymore; however, that was not true.  Once Brutus found out the Cassius was dead, he wanted to kill himself too.  This is a whole lot of drama for no reason.  I think Shakespeare could have done better here. 


Also, like CJ and Kayla both said, the details and plot of this entire play is very typical of Shakespeare.  There were murders, battles, suicides, and even ghosts.  We have seen it all several times before, but it is interesting to see how Shakespeare slightly changes it up with each play he writes.  

Monday, April 4, 2016

Similarities...

I have a feeling that most of our blog posts are going to be similar...

WTF SHAKESPEARE? Honestly, it's the same thing with you... Backstabbing, ghosts, and suicide.

Okay. Let me start with what bothered me first - all this squabble between Cassius and Brutus. It feels sassy, petty, and completely unnecessary. It angered me just reading it - the two of them going on about how they no longer like one another for such dumb reasons. It was like reading break up texts. Only the couple is in like 5th grade and Jessica is breaking up with Jeremy because he said something mean to her best friend Tiffany but Jessica didn't even like Tiffany all that much in the first place!

The ghost thing was so...predictable. C'mon! Now that Brutus is in charge, he has to go to war to defend his place as leader and the night before, while everyone is asleep, the ghost of his victim comes to haunt him in his sleep? CJ was right - we've heard that before. Been there, done that, am I right? While it does add a very surreal and creepy aspect to the story, the fact that we've seen it before...by the same author, makes it boring. It's as if William Shakespeare just has a template in which he fills in the character's names and forms of death.

Speaking of death - can we talk about Brutus' lack of emotion towards Portia's death? She swallowed burning coals for goodness sake - that's hardcore. She must have been so incredibly concerned at the possible loss of her husband, and/or perhaps torn up about her own life in order to kill herself in such a malicious way. I personally find it odd how Brutus just shrugged it off so easily.

We talked in class about the rule of Elizabeth and how Caesar may have been based on what was going on in society at the time. I don't know enough about the real people during Elizabethan times to determine how accurately the stories matched up, but I am strongly inclined to believe that Julius Caesar is based on it. We've always talked about tonypandy being based on true events and facts, and nothing so far has led me to believe that this story would be any different.

Listen Will...


I'm feeling a lot of friggen repetition as we finish up Caesar.  I've heard a lot of this shit before.  I'm sorry Willy Shakes, but you're both long winded aaaaaand redundant.  

The men in all of your plays are honorable whiners.  You love ghosts, murder, and the word love.  


Suicide is your thing.  That is crystal clear my friend.




I feel like Acts 4 and 5 in Caesar weren't your favorite things you've ever written though.  Trust me, they aren't mine either.  Your battle scenes in this piece suuuuuck.  This is like an epic piece of classical literature, but the details suck.  The musings of men in tents aren't the juicy stuff here man.  Real valor is on the battle field.  Also suicide before ever entering enemy engagement is rather cowardly.

I also feel like you want us to believe all men are assholes.  Brutus killed on a suspicion backed by mutinous whispers that surrounded him.  The other conspirators had minimal pictures painted of what sort of men they really were, except that they were seditious followers... Except Cassius, that dude was a complete douche...and a dangerous one.  Antony was on a war path.  He saw that Brutus' cause was noble, buuuut his main man Caesar was dead and someone had to pay.  Honestly, pretty much everyone except Antony died... really Will?  





As to whether Caesar needed to be killed; I really don't think so.  He was no Hitler.   Actually he seems a bit like a Communist or a Socialist and Quite a few nations seem perfectly content with those ideals.  (Not here in the US though, please no...politics, I digress).

This play leaves me wishing Caesar were still alive because I'm not so sure there was a Roman that could control that shit show quite like he.  The Roman empire doesn't really have anyone around today for me to ask about it, sooooooo...

Actually now that I'm done ranting and I'm over my disdain for your bloated prose; it's not your fault.  You were about 2/3 of the way historically accurate, but why?  You were writing a great piece to influence the people of your times... surely you could improve upon the plight of these men? Surely someone could actually fight his own foes? Surely... oh forget it! 

Tuesday, March 8, 2016

Rome...

I am going to stray from the main ideas and run to the side note. Clearly they threw as much money into this series as they did blood.

The book for me kind of rumbled on from incident to incident. There was no fluid story line. It was like someone was trying to shove information into brain without a break. (#math). Each person has different character qualities that can be picked up in the descriptions and accounts of the text, but the show does better. The book (kind of like my blog) just rambles on. This guy killed this guy, then killed this guy until he was dead, then fought another battle so hes a good general, and pirates.

The movie even tho it is made to be dramatic at least it gives us more of a timeline, kind of like a chapter breakdown. We get to see character facial expressions and can read body language. We get to see what type of living situation each is accustomed to. Apparently wardrobes back then were top notch. The parts between the bloodshed and sex scenes bring light to a character. For example, When Julius got executed we saw a lot of angry dudes killing him dead. It was a collective effort until it was Brutus was up for stab. I got more of the sense that it was almost like a sad mercy killing until he actually thrust the dagger into Julius.

I enjoyed and had a better understanding of the films based on the books. Usually the books are better because we can fill in the blanks with our own imagination. The Shakespearean texts are harder to follow. A lot harder. More times than not the book is better than the movie also. Of course like most time than not the movie is varied from the book. I do not think the film did justice to the characters either. What I am also curious about is what in the hell were they doing with their hands when they were speaking. Like seriously... who does that. Only person that comes to mind is Ricky Bobby. I think they watched Ricky on the news and took a page from his book.

Rome

Well for starters, it was much more entertaining to watch what we read about in Plutarch, especially on such a grand scale. Watching the same moments on a low budget production would not have the same effect. When we think of this era of Rome, we think about lavishness and extravagance and the show did not disappoint when it came to this. For example, the celebration of Caesar being appointed dictator was very grand in scale and fun to watch. However, the scene where that poor guy was hung in front of everyone was a little difficult to watch.

Another scene that was difficult to watch was Caesar’s assassination. Though it was quite brutal, it is what actually happened and as a viewer, we were able to capture the emotion experienced by the murders, particularly Brutus, that was not captured in our reading. The emotion of the character’s made them seem like real people as opposed to just someone we are reading about in a historical text.

This just brings it back to our discussion of how we interact with different types of media. Reading Plutarch was challenging, but watching the same stories unfold in Rome was entertaining and engaged my interest. Additionally, I saw these “lives” we read about actually become lives! Watching the characters we get a much better sense of their attitudes and their emotions, which make them much more real than reading about them.


Another aspect of the show that I found really interesting was the focus on the women, Servilia and Atia. There is not an in depth mention of them in Plutarch, but they did, at least according to the show, played a large in role in how a lot of the events played out, like Servilia’s subtle urging for Brutus to kill Caesar. I think this added an interesting dynamic to the show, as well as to the history of the events. Too bad Plutarch did not write a Lives about the women of ancient Rome. Those would have been great stories to tell!

HBO's Rome

Before I even get started discussing my thoughts on the show and all of the in-depth analysis, I think its necessary to congratulate HBO on making phenomenal shows that have the ability to entrance an audience. You go Glen Coco.



Getting back to what is actually relevant though, which medium did I prefer? Me being me, I thought HBO's Rome was the more enjoyable experience overall. Seeing history come to life in a television show or feature film is a truly special experience because these companies have the funds to create accurate replications of what the locations actually looked like. When it comes to a book, one must rely on their imagination to fill create the scene and while that is a good ability to have, sometimes it does not do justice.

I absolutely loved the sets in the show. They were articulate and detailed. The forum was outstanding and the rooms where the scenes took place were nothing short of elaborate. Today, green screens have become so overused that people forget what it is like to have actual sets. In episode 10, I was only able to spot out three or four instances where a green screen was used. Almost all of the episode was practical and that gets an A+ in my book.

The acting was great as well. Were all of the characters outstanding? No. But they each played their respective roles well. It would be interesting to see the show today if they had the budget that Game of Thrones or the Walking Dead has. Perhaps a reboot?

Well, seeing as how Game of Thrones actually has about three of the actors from Rome, maybe they already did?



Another aspect that I personally enjoyed about the show was the intro music by Jeff Beal and his score throughout the show. It fit so well and never did the music seem out of place. In fact, this is one of the only shows I can recall in recent memory where there were long periods of time were there was no music playing. The show runners relied on the acting abilities to drive the drama and move the plot forward.

Oh and the show is graphic which is always an added bonus of HBO shows. Since it is a premium channel, they can do whatever the hell they want and the scene where Caesar gets murdered was graphic as it should be.

Well, that about sums up my thinking on the show.

Rome

I have to say when Dr.MB mentioned that we would be watching two episodes of Rome I have to admitted I was a little excited. I had never actually seen the episodes but have heard about the series.  I much rather watch a movie based off of something then to read the book first. Although Rome is a British-American-Italian historical drama television series and does not have a book published, it all ties together with what we've been discussing in class. Before watching the two episodes I read the facts about the show itself and I find it amazing, in order to re-in act history it took 750 actors and extras for the Caesar's Triumph" scene.

I knew before watching Rome I was aware that the series was based on history and drama surrounding violent transformation of Roman Republic made into Roman Empire. I feel like this series portrays higher contact of sexual activities then we have heard about in the books and readings that we have read thus far. These series showed what happened back in the day, who's to say this is how it was? The book portrayed something different, but don't all books when kind of telling the same story.

Brutus is team Caesar, he even says that Caesar has wisdom and mercy he pledges loyalty to him and urges others to do the same.  Caesar demands that whoever was against him and wanted him dead needs to join him and others in creating new Rome. While watching I noticed there were banners, wash statues and bird cases. They made a big deal of the preparation for the Triumph. I was shocked when Antony had Caesars back and didn't go run and hide when others wanted him dead. You also could definitely tell Antony definitely loved women in Rome. When watching these episodes you can actually see the different personalities from each individual not what someone else is portraying in writing. When watching this movie it was interesting to see the other members of the crew interact with the main characters we have talked about.

These episodes kinda make me want to watch Rome from the beginning to really get all the details of modern history of Rome.