As many classmates probably felt the same, I honestly thought The Daughter of Time was just another typical one of those novels/books that professors assign to read that I just skim through before class and hope for the best. I decided to give this book a chance because it was a mystery. New year, new mindset? Ha, maybe.
In the beginning chapters, Alan Grant is given a challenge by his actress friend, Marta Hallard, which was to solve the oldest unsolved case. Challenge accepted. I put myself into his shoes, well, rather his hospital bed, because I wanted to understand his excitement. There's a certain rush you get when you see that you're making progress in a mystery that has never been solved. He uses different resources such as books and people but I kind of sat back and thought to myself, "Why didn't he check to see how reliable these sources are?" I understand that there was no internet back then but still, we have known for a long time that not everything said or written on paper is to be believed.
As I reached Chapter 7 when Grant realizes that More's account of Richard III couldn't possibly be reliable because More was a mere 5-years-old when Richard III took the throne. Let's just take a minute to think about that time frame. It doesn't match up. Awwww, Grant was making progress. What a disappointment to read that he couldn't use that to help unravel the mystery so basically he had to start over.
I just couldn't help to think that this is exactly how Alan Grant felt when he finally understood that all of the information that he had received up to chapter 7 was bullcrap. He had to be lying in the hospital bed in the worst mood ever. Think about it, whenever we think that we're on to something and realize that we got nothing, we typically feel like giving up and/or moving on but he couldn't do that. He's put too much work into it. With this setback, it only makes me more intrigued to keep reading to find out what happens next.
Tuesday, January 26, 2016
What can I believe?
I can definitely trust the information that I read in my
textbooks, right? Aren’t they just
filled with facts about what happened in the past? But where and who is all
that information coming from?!? I don’t
know what to believe anymore!
That is definitely how The
Daughter of Time is making me feel. On
Grant’s quest to discover the truth about Richard III, he realizes that
different sources of history tell different accounts about the life of
Richard. There is no way he could know
what ACTUALLY happened unless he lived during that time. Yet, we are taught in schools with the aid of
textbook and we are just supposed to trust what is written. At the same time, our parents or teachers
probably taught us: “don’t believe everything you see/read.”
This is just like articles found on the internet. While I’m scrolling through Facebook and
reading a few of the articles that my friends’ shared, I usually make a
conscious effort not to believe everything that I read. I have fallen for those fake or misleading
articles too many times. But because we
are taught not to believe everything we read, why do we still do it outside of
the internet? We shouldn’t automatically
believe the words in our textbooks just because they are “scholarly” or educational
tools. The authors of history books were
probably not present during the times they wrote about, so how can they be sure
about anything? They must have gotten
their information elsewhere and there is no way of knowing what is true and
what is false.
On another note about this topic, we must be aware of author
biases. I was taught that every author
has a bias and sometimes their biases show (even when trying to be as unbiased
as possible.) If this is the case, the
authors of textbooks are biased too.
This means that readers might only get the information that the author
believed or wanted to share, not the full story. Maybe this was the case with the books
written about Richard III. It seems that
people had very strong opinions about him, so that is why textbooks portray him
as a villain.
I think that The
Daughter of Time is reinforcing a lesson that we all know very well. We can’t be too quick to trust what we
read. Our textbooks cannot be completely
accurate because the authors have not experienced all of history or know
everything that happened. Even biases
can get in the way of the truth.
Labels:
history,
Susannah Noppenberger,
The Daughter of Time,
truth
Richard III
When reading this novel “The Daughter of Time” I thought it wasn’t going to be interesting and relate to my life at all but in fact I was wrong. After reading the first couple chapters I started to picture myself in this book, I work in a hospital and often wonder what people do and think when they are sick, they read books but what do they read about? In this book he clearly reads about history and one person killing another, the author makes it all seem so real but the real question is how do we know this to be true. Just because one told us this is what happened. Another thing that got me thinking is when Grant asked Midget “what do you want to look at that face for? Who was he anyway” He didn’t know who he was looking at and made such a bold statement, many people in society told look at someone and make a comment without knowing that person. Sometimes they just say something that’s not nice or make a comment based off of what they heard from someone else. Just like Grant did about Richard III. It’s just amazing how a book based off of many years ago can still relate to people today and how they act and what they think. With this book to be a start to think class I’m interested to see what we read next. Based on this book history are events that are believed to have taken place and talked about many years later.
Everyone stay safe in the snow, could you imagine what Richard III would do if he would get this much snow?
Everyone stay safe in the snow, could you imagine what Richard III would do if he would get this much snow?
Monday, January 25, 2016
Making It Up
Josephine Tey's book The Daughter of Time poses many questions that a reader wouldn't otherwise be asking. What is "history"? How can we know if something is truly fact? Is it actually possible to judge a book by it's cover? What stuck with me the most was the word "tonypandy" which I still cannot find a proper definition for, but we'll get to that.
Discovering that only some of what once was fact regarding Richard III is true, made Grant and the readers question how much of our history is actually just stories people told to fill in the blanks of what they didn't want people to know. When you think about it, that's how the education system has always taught us. The first time we learned about Thanksgiving, it was the most basic and pleasant description that adults could think to tell children. As we grew, the story became more violent and harsh. Now that we're grown, we say we "know" what happened when Columbus came to America, and we "know" what happened at the Boston Tea Party and Pearl Harbor and we "know" that the United States went to the moon in 1969. (Debating the moon landing is for another time) My point is that by these few accounts of false history having been passed through centuries of writings, can make an individual question any history book's legitimacy.
This is where the question "What is history?" meets the question "What is real?" It becomes difficult to answer when you cannot pinpoint a definition for the two. What we know to be true and real, may not have been. When I was six, I knew that unicorns were real! I was determined that the French took them all and were hiding them in the Catacombs. That happened in the past, but does that make it real? Does that make it history? In the novel, Grant and Carradine use the term "tonypandy" to describe false history. The two learn that their most reliable source for accounts of Richard III's life, was not reliable at all. Through other thorough investigating, they come to a conclusion about Richard III's true character, but who's to say that other sources were 100% accurate as well?
If you haven't noticed, this book has turned me into a major skeptic. It astounds me that there is no known individual who kept account of Richard III's life, leading to people making their own stories. The book really challenged what is and is not history, and it seems to define the term as actual events, whether known or not. While I agree with this, having said in class that history is something that happened in the past, I think it is flexible.
I mean to say that while history should be recorded as the true events that occurred, it is not always so. Sometimes there are gaps and unanswered questions - things people should have taken note of but didn't, or all records of the event became lost somehow. People would go mad if these gaps were not filled and questions remained open! Then again...sometimes "I don't know" can be a legitimate answer...
This is where the question "What is history?" meets the question "What is real?" It becomes difficult to answer when you cannot pinpoint a definition for the two. What we know to be true and real, may not have been. When I was six, I knew that unicorns were real! I was determined that the French took them all and were hiding them in the Catacombs. That happened in the past, but does that make it real? Does that make it history? In the novel, Grant and Carradine use the term "tonypandy" to describe false history. The two learn that their most reliable source for accounts of Richard III's life, was not reliable at all. Through other thorough investigating, they come to a conclusion about Richard III's true character, but who's to say that other sources were 100% accurate as well?If you haven't noticed, this book has turned me into a major skeptic. It astounds me that there is no known individual who kept account of Richard III's life, leading to people making their own stories. The book really challenged what is and is not history, and it seems to define the term as actual events, whether known or not. While I agree with this, having said in class that history is something that happened in the past, I think it is flexible.
I mean to say that while history should be recorded as the true events that occurred, it is not always so. Sometimes there are gaps and unanswered questions - things people should have taken note of but didn't, or all records of the event became lost somehow. People would go mad if these gaps were not filled and questions remained open! Then again...sometimes "I don't know" can be a legitimate answer...
tonypandy... one hell of a word.
We all have a general understanding of the message of The Daughter of Time. How bias, perspective, and history add to the mystery of the already little know events surrounding Richard III. We are taken into the authors thought process and research of the king. Recorded history itself is a mystery because of popular understanding and truism, victors write the history. I find it interesting that a single idea can shape the course of history. This is evident not only in today's world but understood by individuals in the past. It happens over and over, for example the 5th of November nearly 120 years after king Richard III. The 5th of November is still practiced today in an obscure way, now dubbed the million mask march.
I was a little put off when I first started reading the book. I kept coming across words I have never seen and didn't understand. So naturally I had to look them up. It was an annoying process for me. As I continued reading and started to get pulled into the pages, coming across a word I did not understand was like being interrupted during a movie. On the quest to discovering what the author of the mystery novel wanted to say about history, I was on a quest of my own trying to discover what words meant. Eventually I could understand them... until "tonypandy"
I focused on this term in trying to come up with a visual way of understanding it. I found the solution in Grant. Grant, like myself can pick up certain clues when he looks at faces. Looking at the Kings face I came up with a visual. I imagined the king was in the middle of circle of people. He was surrounded by the Tudors. They were playing the child's game of telephone. As information (history) got passed it continued to get muddied. On the outside of the ring were other people writing their accounts of Richard. The Tudors of course were bullies and wouldn't let the others join in the game. Thus we have tonypandy. Now we have conflicting accounts of history, facts, and perspectives surrounding Richard. No wonder he has that facial expression. His eye was twitching while he was taking his ring off. He was furious at the mockery and didn't want to hurt his "king" hand.
Funny how an idea, in this case a visual idea with the help of a portrait can "accurately" shape history 60% of the time, throughout all of time.
I was a little put off when I first started reading the book. I kept coming across words I have never seen and didn't understand. So naturally I had to look them up. It was an annoying process for me. As I continued reading and started to get pulled into the pages, coming across a word I did not understand was like being interrupted during a movie. On the quest to discovering what the author of the mystery novel wanted to say about history, I was on a quest of my own trying to discover what words meant. Eventually I could understand them... until "tonypandy"
I focused on this term in trying to come up with a visual way of understanding it. I found the solution in Grant. Grant, like myself can pick up certain clues when he looks at faces. Looking at the Kings face I came up with a visual. I imagined the king was in the middle of circle of people. He was surrounded by the Tudors. They were playing the child's game of telephone. As information (history) got passed it continued to get muddied. On the outside of the ring were other people writing their accounts of Richard. The Tudors of course were bullies and wouldn't let the others join in the game. Thus we have tonypandy. Now we have conflicting accounts of history, facts, and perspectives surrounding Richard. No wonder he has that facial expression. His eye was twitching while he was taking his ring off. He was furious at the mockery and didn't want to hurt his "king" hand.
Funny how an idea, in this case a visual idea with the help of a portrait can "accurately" shape history 60% of the time, throughout all of time.
What really makes a villain, according to Alan Grant?
When we think of villains, we think of the classic ones from
popular Disney movies. Their intent is usually pretty clear, gain power,
destroy the good guy and turn the world into their evil little empire. I can’t
help but think of the seven deadly sins when it comes to my idea of the bad
guy. Greed, gluttony, and vanity, especially. They don’t shy away from what
they want to accomplish, and often their reputation is not one of reputable
quality. It’s open and shut – defeat the bad guy and live happily ever after.
That’s one lesson Disney has done a good job of. Drilling this idea that good
vs. evil is so black and white.
Grant is a detective, he believes in facts, figures. He
doesn’t trust what he hears, he has to be able to prove it. I think that’s why
it might be difficult for him to see Richard III as a villain. He tries to understand this man, and what
might have made him want to kill his nephews. It’s so interesting to me that he
interviews each person that comes into his room about Richard. As if they’re
suspects and he wants to dissect their opinions, which could very well be
motive. It draws the comparison of hearsay, and what is actual fact. Most
people just accept what they think they already know about history, but Grant
is determined to find out what really happened to the boys. He wants to know
why Richard actually has such a bad reputation.
Carradine and Grant conclude that Henry VII was a pretty ruthless
guy. His rivals were put to death. While with Richard, his allies and foes,
were allowed to have a different opinion, and could live amongst one another.
After Grant and Carradine spend all of this time uncovering facts, just to
realize that no one really knew the boys were even mission for a period of
time, really forces him to take a step back and reflect. He was sure that
Richard III wasn’t guilty, and being the brilliant detective that he is, he was
able to uncover the truth. Grant isn’t quick to jump to conclusions, as he
relies on his own intuition to determine the character of others. By studying
the portrait of Richard, Grant wanted to know the real story behind the man
with a bad reputation.
Grant ends up accomplishing quite a bit. He even begins to
show favor towards his nurses, who he once enjoyed making fun of. I wonder if
he considered them to be villains, forcing him to eat hospital food or read
stale books. In a way, I’d say he solved his way to his own recovery.
History and Tonypandy, is there a Truth?
How do we think of history? Well
when I think of history, I think of past events that have shaped the world that
we live in today. The one thing that I
never thought of was whether the information was correct. Also in history, such
as in textbooks, the names and dates can be correct, but the events can be told
in a way that makes it bias. Grant was not going to take the information from
some of the sources without knowing who wrote them and what their background
was in knowing Richard III. This does not
make the sources correct just because those who wrote the history were alive
during the time of Richard III.
Grant looks at all different types
of history, a lot of the time a new source arises when he asks himself a new
question and wants to know more about an event or a person. I wonder why most of the time he does not
consider the material that he has gone through before to see if it can be
found. As you know Grant did look
through a lot of sources and I understand that he had to sort out the ones who
were fake and the ones that had “truth”, but when he was asking more questions
why didn’t he go back to some of the original sources? Grant wanted to prove
that he could read faces; maybe that’s why he had to use so many sources so
that he could get the answer he wanted.
This brings us to Tonypandy, which can
be seen throughout the book. How can we define Tonypandy? After reading the
book I have come up with the conclusion that Tonypandy is history that has been
stretched so that readers can stay intrigued. Think about it have you ever
embellished a story so that other people will stay interested? When Grant started reading Thomas More’s History of Richard III he wanted to know
more information until he found out that Thomas More was Henry VIII’s
chancellor and was only eight when Richard III died.
Grant and Carradine wanted to find
an answer to the question of whether Richard III killed his nephews or not,
they believe that they got around the Tonypandy and got the “truth”. Maybe it is just what they wanted to hear, either way it remains a mystery to me.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








